ICL is not enough

Intercultural learning has become a key work area in European youth training during the last fifteen years. Nevertheless, approaches that have been consolidated and widely reproduced during this period are no longer adequate to the realities in which young people live and practice youth work.

Theme (Category)

The long-awaited discussion document on intercultural learning that has been developed by Dr Gavan Titley in follow-up to the Council of Europes Directorate of Youth and Sports Long Term Training Course “Intercultural Learning” — LTTC ICL. The document draws heavily on recent research carried out in the context of the research covenant between the Council of Europe and the European Commission and sets a useful precendent for further synergies between the research and training practise fields.

Taken in context with and close relation to the documents recently produced on quality standards in European level youth worker training, this document could serve as a basis for the improvement of the approach to and practise of intercultural learning. Stay tuned and read a review soon here at nonformality.org!

Copies have already been sent to the participants of the LTTC ICL 2003-2004 and the team of that course. It will be uploaded to the European Knowledge Centre and the Council of Europe is printing paper copies available for distribution. Please note that the document’s status is July 2005 although no date appears in the PDF version.

Wishing you interesting reading! Should you have comments, please do not hesitate to contact the author of this article, Yael, or the author of the publication, Gavan.

Gavan on Intercultural learning (pdf, 400 kb)



This entry was posted on a wonderful Friday which was September 9th, 2005 at 15:32.

It is filed under Intercultural learning and intercultural dialogue and tagged with the keywords , , .

Would you like this article on paper? No problem! | Print This Post



7 Comments so far » Leave a comment » Leave a TrackBack
RSS feed for comments on this post.

This report is very timely and takes into account some of the burning issues regarding intercultural learning and the way it is used when working with young people. Some of these issues were discussed during a research seminar on “Resituating Culture� organised by the Partnership in Youth Research between the Council of Europe and the European Commission in 2003, which was followed by a highly successful book of the same name.
This year, in May 2006 a research seminar on the themes of Diversity, Human Rights and Participation will attempt to submit these nebulous terms to the same kind of critical analysis that intercultural learning has been undergoing over the last 3 years. The threads of the Resituating Culture debate will be picked up and added to. We will ask what does it really mean when we say that we live in a diverse world. How can the gap between human rights in theory and in practice be bridged? Or is this indeed an adequate framework for struggling for social justice? What are the ways in which participation can be made more than just a slogan? Does it make sense to speak about democratic citizenship when so many among us have no de facto chance to participate, either politically or economically, in their societies.

All this and much more…

The deadline for applications is March 10.

All are welcome to apply by registering on http://www.youth-knowledge.net
All information on the seminar can be found in the area “Research Activities�.

Indeed, and see my comment on Lene Morgensen’s article on ICL in this edition. It also picks up on several key problems regarding ICL theory and practise in youth work outlined in Gavan Tiltey’s paper. It’s not only a matter of the construction of activities around static notions of culture. The problem is also one of a certain kind of unmediated altruism (viva tolerance! human rights! democracy!) that is being promoted by many youth programmes, advertently or inadvertently. Such terms, and the entire issue of the intercultural, are POLITICAL and must be treated as such. Hence, ICL is a form of learning for political literacy, in my opinion.

That is one of the reason’s why I really hope that the session on Human Rights during the upcoming research seminar can address the depoliticisation of the “human” and the seriously problematic reign of “rights”. I dont mean to say Human Rights are not important, but it worries me that they are considered enough (in other words, it is the legal rights which count and not their respect and sanction). The rhetoric of so many governments, institutions and NGOs goes in this direction, unfortunately. Considering the continuing failure of anyone to deal with the ongoing food crisis in Africa or the negative consequences for civil liberties of the war on terror, how can we meaningfully speak about human rights? Admittedly, in practise, human rights education as proposed in the DYS HRE programme does go some way to addressing such problems and tensions. But, for as long as human rights education remains the preserve of the civic sector, it will remain maginalised to some extent. During the first “all different – all equal” campaign we used to say that even minorities need intercultural learning. Today, I believe more than ever that governments and institutions desperately need human rights education.

I plan to use the Derdians in China in April. However I will work with 2 Chiense groups and make the engineers one Chinese group and the Derdians also as a Chinese group. We take this simulation game as a prelude to enter in conlfict management and central German & Chiense cultural standards as well as an exrecise for feed back. Even if stereotypes may enter we shall make the Chinese the experts and let them decide where they think that the Derdians may live.

[...] Gavan (2005): Plastic, Political and Contingent. Culture and Intercultural Learning in DYS activities. Discussion document based on the evaluation of the LTTC Intercultural Learning and recent research [...]

[...] by Gavan Titley’s paper on intercultural learning in DYS COE-activities (also found on this site here). Culture is not a thing, it is a [...]

[...] In 2005, a discussion document on intercultural learning was published in follow-up to the Council of Europe’s Directorate of Youth and Sports Long Term Training Course “Intercultural Learning” — LTTC ICL (the paper is available here). [...]

[...] Gavan (2005): Plastic, Political and Contingent. Culture and Intercultural Learning in DYS activities. Discussion document based on the evaluation of the LTTC Intercultural Learning and recent research [...]

Leave a comment

You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

Please consider the following advice before commenting:
  1. Think before you type.
  2. Don't be an idiot. Comments containing personal attacks or abusive language will be deleted.
  3. Don't argue with an idiot - people reading may not be able to tell the difference.
  4. And: Comments are moderated to prevent spam. So:
  5. Please don't get nervous if your comment does not show up immediately. And:
  6. Do not enter it a second time - no need for that. Very well then!